The Republicans are making an effort to remove Bob Barr from the ballot. They are using Cumberland County GOP chair Vic Stabile as the means by which to do this. I know know Vic well enough having been a Committeeman in Cumberland County as well as the past chair of the Cumberland County Young Republicans.
My commentary isn’t really about Vic - he’s just doing what the party bosses have asked him to do.
My commentary is directed to the statewide party leadership and the McCain campaign.
First, why on earth would you choose a county chairman that has lost registered Republicans? Why not go to York or Lancaster, I think they’ve gained registered Republicans. I’m sure you can find a county somewhere in this state that has gained registered Republicans. It’s almost like you are trying to throw Stabile under the bus and make him the easy target for criticism. There’s a lot to be critical of his handling of the county GOP, but gee, do you really need to add to it. Unless of course he volunteered for the duty, in which he deserves all the criticism. But again, the “leadership” should have seen the criticism coming.
Second, when I read the article it made me mad. Then that subsided to sadness. Sad, because the Republican party in Pennsylvania now reminds me of a patient that has been told he or she has cancer. Many people don’t know how to handle this information. Some even get mad at the messenger. This is similar to the state of the GOP in Pennsylvania. Reformers have been telling the Republican leadership that it has serious disease and must change its life or else suffer the consequences. The reformers have told the GOP over and over and over again, yet, like the patient who can’t accept the news, it has lashed out at the messanger, dug in and insisted that it is just fine.
This is sad, because we all see what’s happening, but the patient refuses to accept reality. At some point the cancer patient who refuses treatment will likely die a slow and painful death - all of which is preventable with appropriate treatment. But as you know, the longer a sick person waits for treatment, the more difficult the treatment and the less likely the treatment will work. The same is true for the GOP today.
Third, Lowman Henry’s excellent commentary on this episode is a great example of how the GOP is pushing people away. Given recent comments by McCain statewide chairman Bob Asher equating conservatives to Nazis and now this push to kick Bob Barr off the ballot, I have come to the conclusion that the leadership of the GOP is not only inept and truly powerless, but also scared. People who are afraid become angry. People who are afraid attack. People who feel they have no control of a situation will do something, even something stupid, in order to get some feeling of control, even if the long term effects of that action create more powerlessness and fear.
The GOP has gone from its humble beginnings founded on an idea that all men are created equal and the cause of abolition of slavery was vitally important to the survival of the nation to a party whose leadership is consumed with power, arrogance, and egotism. The average registered Republican has sent message after message after message to the leadership, and it has fallen on deaf ears. Now people are leaving the party who has ignored them and the people in positions of power are afraid and so they must blame someone for their downfall. People consumed with power, arrogance and egotism are blind to the fact that it was they themselves who brought about their own downfall.
Fourth, the way to win votes is not by eliminating options as Stabile proposes to do, but rather win over hearts and mind in support of ideas and people. Scaring people into voting for your candidate is a poor strategy. Once the fear is gone, people have no reason to stay with you and often resent you for putting them in fear.
Lastly, I’d like to offer some free advice to the McCain campaign. Any regular reader of this blog knows that I’m not a supporter of John McCain. The remote possibility that I will vote for him on election day keeps getting smaller and smaller by the day because of people associated with Mr. McCain’s campaign. I’m still waiting to hear a good reason why I should vote for John McCain beyond the “lesser of two evils” argument. If that’s the best you’ve got, you might as well quit your campaign now. Please understand that I’ve heard and seen plenty of reasons to vote against McCain. They far outweigh the positives for me. I’d really like to see a presidential candidate who has leadership ability. I don’t even have to agree with this person on issues. Right now I don’t see leadership from either of the two major candidates. One leaves a trail of organizations that fall apart after he leaves and who has to re-re-re-re-relaunch campaigns and the other is a state senator running for President who supposedly has great oratory skills, but somehow I’m not impressed.
It’s as if neither of these two want my vote - they are both making it easy for me to vote for a third party candidate or write someone in on election day for President. How sad.